In November 1980, Jeannette Bishop May and her friend Gabriella Guerin vanished in a snowstorm in a small Italian town, sparking an investigation that initially suggested an accident. However, the emergence of suspicious telegrams, connections to the art world, and potential mafia involvement complicated the narrative. As inconsistencies in witness statements and unexplained circumstances arose, theories about abduction and criminal connections developed. Despite extensive searches and public appeals for information, the case remains unresolved, prompting ongoing community engagement to uncover the truth behind the mysterious disappearances.

The podcast episode narrates the tragic murder of cyclist Mariah Wilson, focusing on the complex emotions of jealousy and betrayal that led to her shooting by Caitlin Armstrong, the girlfriend of Colin Strickland, who was the last person seen with Mariah. The investigation unveils premeditated elements and examines the intense relationships between the individuals involved. Following the murder, Caitlin eludes capture leading to an international manhunt, which ultimately ends with her arrest in Costa Rica. The trial reveals critical evidence linking her to the crime, highlighting issues of obsession and motive.

In this episode, hosts Woody Overton and Morgan Baggett discuss the ongoing investigation into Bradley's disappearance, emphasizing community involvement in seeking justice. They highlight the recovery of Bradley's vehicle, received tips, and the significance of a letter he wrote before going missing. The hosts explore the implications of the letter found by his mother, discuss law enforcement's dismissive attitude towards it, and raise concerns about arson incidents related to the case. Eyewitness accounts provide crucial insights, particularly as new evidence regarding a murder emerges, underscoring the complexity and urgency of the investigation.

Karen Reed faces serious charges in the murder case of her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O'Keefe, who died during a blizzard. The episode narrates the tumultuous events surrounding O'Keefe's death, the subsequent investigations, and trials that stirred public interest. Key arguments include allegations of Reed's intoxication and her innocence claims amid a perceived biased investigation. The discussion examines both the emotional impact on those involved and the complexities of the judicial process, including the influence of public opinion and media scrutiny on legal outcomes.

In this episode, Andrea Dunlop introduces 'Deep Cover: The Truth About Sarah,' a true crime podcast that uncovers the story of Sarah Cavanaugh, who falsely portrayed herself as a decorated veteran and cancer fighter. The narrative unveils her six-year deception, highlighting core themes of identity, trust, and the moral dilemmas surrounding fabricated self-presentations. Insights from journalists and personal encounters unravel the complexities of her charade, illustrating the profound impact of such deception on relationships and community.

The podcast explores the tragic story of Maria Martin and the notorious Red Barn murder of 1827. Maria's life, marked by societal stigma as an unwed mother and her relationship with William Corder, leads to her disappearance and eventual death. After disturbing dreams plague her stepmother, Ann, a search uncovers Maria's body in the Red Barn, indicating foul play. William's trial reveals contradictions in his claims of innocence, resulting in a swift guilty verdict and a death sentence, reflecting harsh societal views on justice in the 19th century.

The case of Michael Shaver, who vanished in November 2015 after an argument with his wife, Lori, unfolds through a series of incidents highlighting their toxic, abusive relationship. Lori's conflicting narratives about Michael's disappearance, coupled with her quick emotional transitions and suspicious behaviors, led friends and family to question her involvement. As detectives unearthed evidence of a violent altercation and ultimately discovered Michael's remains buried in their backyard, Lori faced arrest for murder. The trial revealed complexities of their past, accusations of domestic violence, and a controversial defense strategy that shaped public perception. The chilling case illustrates the devastating consequences of domestic abuse, manipulation, and deception.

The episode explores 'The Mad Bomber of New York,' beginning with a bomb discovered at Consolidated Edison Company in 1940. Over the next five years, the bomber carried out a series of attacks, targeting prominent locations and sending threatening letters. Following a pause during World War II, he resumed bombings in 1951, escalating his tactics while evading capture. The investigation revealed the complexities and psychological aspects surrounding the bomber's motives and calls for justice against Consolidated Edison, leading to a terrifying reign of terror for New Yorkers.

In Chester, Pennsylvania, a young college athlete's disappearance leads to the grim discovery of her body. The hosts explore the investigation, focusing on the suspects, particularly one with a troubling past. They highlight the local crime rates, the impact of the city's history on criminal behavior, and the psychological complexities involved. The narrative emphasizes the brutal nature of the murder, the challenges faced by law enforcement in resolving the case, and the social issues tied to the community's struggles.

Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto explore the shocking case of Jon and Carie Hallford, whose funeral home turned from a compassionate facility into a site of horror. The Hallfords neglected deceased bodies, substituting concrete for ashes, causing immense grief among families while evading justice. Alongside this true crime narrative, the episode discusses the evolution of funeral practices in America, the significance of empathy in the death care industry, and highlights personal stories of families impacted by loss, culminating in a serious investigation revealing unsanitary conditions at the Hallford funeral home.