The episode features a series of chilling true scary stories, starting with a narrative of Jack Thompson's dangerous expedition in Africa to hunt man-eating lions, highlighting themes of bravery and sacrifice. It transitions into unsettling family dynamics during Thanksgiving, revealing deep-seated issues through traumatic recollections, such as substance abuse and emotional confrontation. Additional stories unfold ominously, including a game warden's encounter with a mysterious creature, a family's panic over an uncle's disappearance, and an ex-soldier's harrowing experiences mentoring rangers in Congo amidst the perils of poaching and armed conflict. The episode culminates with the grim account of Lowell Lee Andrews, who tragically murdered his family during a Thanksgiving weekend.

In August 1993, rafters in the Siberian wilderness discover a traumatized teenage girl who cryptically states, 'They're dead. They're all dead.' This chilling encounter raises questions about the mysteries of Siberia, a region largely misunderstood. The team, led by Lyudmila, faces severe weather conditions during a mountain ascent, testing their survival skills and camaraderie. Meanwhile, a horrifying series of unexplained deaths unfolds among their companions, leaving a young survivor, Valentina, grappling with despair in the midst of chaos. The narrative delves into themes of fear, survival, and the psychological impacts of isolation in extreme environments.

In this episode, Annie Elise interviews Sherri Papini, who discusses her alleged 2016 kidnapping, originally labeled a hoax. Papini insists she was truly abducted, highlighting her fears, fragmented memories of the event, and struggles within her tumultuous relationships. The interview explores the psychological impact of her experiences, particularly regarding her ex-husband and abductor, and delves into allegations of manipulation and control. Throughout the conversation, Papini reflects on her mental health challenges and her desire for accountability regarding her abduction experience, urging for a deeper understanding of consent and the complexity of truth in her narrative.

The episode recounts the mysterious disappearance of Nicholas Barclay, who vanished in 1994 while playing basketball, and reappeared three years later in Spain, claiming he was a victim of a human trafficking ring. The investigation revealed inconsistencies in his identity, leading to the shocking discovery of imposter Frederick Bourdin, who had manipulated the situation for his own benefit. As the investigation unfolded, deep emotional turmoil among Nicholas's family and the complexities of trauma and deception emerged, raising questions about identity and truth.

Sherri Papini discusses her fabricated abduction case, critically reflecting on how media representation has shaped public perception of her narrative. She shares her emotional struggles regarding past documentaries that exploited her family and highlights the manipulation she faced in abusive relationships. Throughout the conversation, Papini examines her motivations for her actions, the psychological trauma she endured, and the subsequent impact on her children and family dynamics. The episode invites listeners to reconsider her story from multiple perspectives, blending personal accountability with broader themes of media bias and trauma recovery.

The hosts celebrate a belated birthday episode while sharing amusing and insightful stories. Em recounts the UFO abduction of Kristina Florence, a tale filled with eerie details and memory loss, raising questions about alien encounters. Christine discusses the unresolved murder case of Jabez Spann, a 14-year-old boy whose disappearance disturbs the Sarasota community. The mix of paranormal narratives and true crime highlights the hosts' humorous yet sensitive exploration of significant real-life issues.

The podcast episode delves into chilling true stories, primarily focusing on a young man's search for his father in a remote Canadian town, where he uncovers family secrets and local legends relating to missing persons. Narratives intertwine as the young man learns of his father's potential involvement in a historic disappearance, which leads him to confront unsettling memories and consider the implications of his father's past. Other segments explore harrowing experiences at gas stations, highlighting themes of personal safety, social tensions in Estonia, and the psychological turmoil faced by communities amid tragedies.

In this episode, Joe Tidy delves into the Vastaamo cyber attack of October 2020, where a hacker known as Ransom Man breached the Vastamo Psychotherapy Center, compromising the personal data of around 33,000 clients. The episode illustrates the attack's ethical implications, highlighting the psychological trauma inflicted on victims whose sensitive therapy notes were threatened with public exposure. Following the hackers' actions, law enforcement undertook a significant investigation, leading to the arrest of notorious hacker Julius Kivimäki. The episode raises important questions regarding data protection and the responsibilities of organizations in safeguarding client information, emphasizing the disturbing fusion of cybercrime and mental health care.

This episode discusses the investigation of Clifford Olson, a notorious serial killer who, despite being known to the RCMP for lesser crimes, managed to evade capture while committing a series of child murders in 1981. Systemic flaws within the police structure allowed Olson to manipulate the investigation and present himself as a cooperative informant, delaying suspicions about his involvement. The narrative emphasizes the emotional impacts on the families of victims like Judy Kozma, whose disappearance and tragic end highlight the inefficiencies in police response and the tragic implications of multiple missing children cases during this period. Ultimately, Olson's controversial deal with the RCMP for information about victims raised significant ethical concerns, sparking public outrage and criticism of police practices.

In this episode, Wendigoon and MeatCanyon explore the unsettling tales surrounding Camp Oakwood, a summer camp shrouded in mystery and horror. The narrative follows Harrison Tracy, a new maintenance worker, as he uncovers the camp's dark history involving cult-like rituals, eerie incidents, and a legacy of violence linked to its founder, Horace Oakwood. As tensions rise among campers and staff, Harrison grapples with trust issues and a traumatic family history, ultimately leading to a chilling climax where sinister rituals are revealed. The episode critiques simplistic horror formats while emphasizing the importance of unsettling complexities in storytelling.