In this episode, the hosts discuss several recent murder cases from various states including Idaho, Missouri, Alabama, and Ohio. They delve into the disturbing murders of Idaho firefighters John Morrison and Frank Harwood, and ongoing legal matters surrounding other murder cases. They also analyze the implications of the retrial of Michael Sockwell, whose wrongful conviction has broader significance for the justice system. Moreover, they highlight trends indicating a decline in murder rates in the U.S., despite the prevailing media focus on crime.

The episode explores the disturbing case of Glen Helzer and the Children of Thunder, focusing on the disappearance and subsequent murder of an elderly couple, Ivan and Annette Steinman. The investigation reveals a bizarre motive tied to financial extortion, as suspects Taylor and Justin Helzer, along with Dawn Godman, commit heinous acts that escalate to multiple murders. The discussion includes the delusional beliefs of Taylor, who claimed divine instruction to train assassins, connecting the horrific crimes to a cult mentality. Ultimately, legal proceedings and mental health issues surrounding the Helzer brothers come to light, highlighting the tragic consequences of their actions.

On July 5, 2003, Sandra Rozzo was murdered, leading investigators to initially suspect her ex-boyfriend, Tracey Humphrey, who had a contentious history with her. As evidence evolved, Tracey's alibi held, while his new wife, Ashley Laney, became implicated in the crime. Driven by jealousy and manipulation, Ashley confessed to murdering Sandra to protect Tracey from allegations of abuse. The case unraveled a complex web of relationships, ultimately revealing Tracey's controlling nature and his role as the mastermind behind the murder. He was convicted and sentenced to life without parole, showcasing the tragic outcomes of manipulation and violence in intimate relationships.

In this Dateline episode, the mysterious disappearance of Allison Foy in 2006 raises alarms about her husband Michael's behavior and his possible involvement. Two years later, her remains and those of Angela Nobles Rothen are discovered, suggesting a potential serial killer. The investigation shifts focus to Tim Iannone, a cab driver linked to both women through witness accounts and a history of violence. Despite circumstantial evidence, a lack of physical connection stalls the case until DNA from a historical rape kit finally ties Iannone to the murders, leading to his arrest and conviction, and offering resolution to the families affected.

In this episode, Deborah Roberts examines the tragic murder of cyclist Moriah Wilson by Caitlin Armstrong, revealing the shocking circumstances surrounding the crime. As the narrative unfolds, the complexities of relationships within the cycling community come to light, particularly the themes of jealousy and rivalry. Audio recordings serve as crucial evidence, and the investigation's intense 43-day manhunt for Armstrong is detailed. The episode also explores Armstrong's calculated escape from custody and the emotional impact of Wilson's legacy, highlighting the intertwining of ambition, friendship, and betrayal.

This episode explores the chilling murder of photographer Linda Lanson at the Suncoast Playboy Club, shortly after the 'Bunny of the Year' contest. Co-hosts Ellyn and Joey discuss the ensuing fear among the Playboy Bunnies and the cultural context of the 1980s, illustrated by the competitive atmosphere within the club. They delve into the efforts of the investigation plagued by inadequacies, leading to the identification of a possible serial killer linked to multiple murders during a frightening summer in Tampa. The episode reflects on the glamour versus the darker realities faced by the Bunnies, highlighted by personal stories and comedic insights.

In this episode, the narrative centers on Frank Carson's arrest in 2015 for a convoluted murder conspiracy involving multiple suspects, including three police officers. The investigation sheds light on possible corruption within law enforcement, as evidence of collusion and suspicious interactions between Carson's associates and police emerge. Key witnesses, conflicting testimonies, and the implications of the case create a complex web of deceit. The prosecutor's observations of Carson's behavior during the trial further fuel the narrative around guilt and the emotional strain on the accused, highlighting the intertwined dynamics of law enforcement and personal relationships in the case.

In this episode, the investigation into the 1988 murder of jewelry salesman Don Vaughn unfolds, starting with the discovery of his decomposed body in a truck at Fort Lauderdale Airport. Homicide detectives determine the cause of death as blunt force trauma and explore various motives, including personal disputes and robbery. The case takes a turn as clues link Vaughn's friend Bruce Weiss to the crime, revealing a deeper conspiracy involving gambling debts. The psychological tactics used during the interrogation lead to confessions that highlight themes of betrayal and calculated violence, ultimately concluding with Weiss's conviction for the murder.

This episode delves into a chilling true crime narrative revolving around Dr. Joseph Saunier, Rochelle Shatina, and Dr. Mike Dixon. The story unfolds a deadly love triangle marked by obsession and betrayal, leading to a shocking murder-for-hire plot. As the investigation progresses, complex personal relationships and motivations emerge, particularly highlighting Dixon's obsession with Shatina and his connections to David Shepard, who ultimately implicates him in the crime. The courtroom drama reveals themes of manipulation, witness credibility, and the tragic consequences of extreme emotional attachment, culminating in a controversial verdict.

The discovery of Korey Kauffman's remains rekindles a complex murder investigation, centering around Robert Woody's unreliable confessions. As the case unfolds, Woody, battling substance abuse and psychological pressures, provides conflicting narratives that prosecutors attempt to piece together against Frank Carson. The interrogation tactics employed reveal the fine line between truth and deception, with Woody's testimonies raising doubts about their reliability and the overarching implications for the ongoing legal battle.